By Cedie Lazaro
The MTV Video Music Awards have long been pop music’s favorite Roman Coliseum—a hyper-visible arena where stars don’t just perform; they offer up their style as a cultural sacrifice. Yet, at the 2025 VMAs after-party circuit, Sabrina Carpenter proved that the most radical modern fashion statement isn’t cutting-edge custom couture. It is the meticulous, high-stakes resurrection of a living artifact.
Stepping into her “Sabrina 54” themed takeover at a Brooklyn nightclub, Carpenter sent fashion archivists into a collective tailspin. Her weapon of choice? An authentic 1975 multi-colored, mirrored ribbon-fringe bodysuit designed by the sultan of sequin himself, Bob Mackie. Originally custom-made for Cher, the garment is a holy grail of television costume history. By pulling this masterpiece from the vault, Carpenter bypassed the modern machine of luxury loans, turning a sweaty after-party into an exclusive, living museum exhibition.
The Provenance: From The Cher Show to Brooklyn
To understand the sheer weight of Carpenter’s sartorial heist, you have to rewind exactly fifty years. In 1975, Bob Mackie was busy rewriting the visual lexicon of the pop diva, using Cher as his ultimate canvas. This specific graphic-lined bodysuit—a dizzying kaleidoscope of strategic cutouts, hand-stitched mirrors, and cascading panels of black, hot pink, and turquoise fringe—was famously worn by Cher during a high-octane, historic television duet with Tina Turner on The Cher Show.
The garment is a masterclass in Mackie’s signature “naked illusion” architecture. It wasn’t just built to sit on a hanger; it was engineered to weaponize movement under harsh studio lights. In 2018, this piece of pop history left private hands at an elite celebrity auction for a surprisingly modest $6,400. But while garments of this caliber are usually destined to die a slow death behind temperature-controlled glass, Carpenter and her stylist, Jared Ellner, decided to return the piece to its natural habitat: a crowded dance floor.
The Technical Execution: The High-Stakes Art of Archival Tailoring
When a rising pop star wears a piece of fashion history, they aren’t just wearing a dress—they are holding a historical document hostage. Unlike modern garments, vintage archival pieces cannot be remade, and altering a piece originally molded to Cher’s iconic frame requires absolute technical wizardry.
Ellner’s styling team had to execute a high-wire act: achieve a flawless aesthetic fit while fiercely protecting a 50-year-old fabric. Keen-eyed fashion sleuths quickly noted subtle modifications made to accommodate Carpenter’s petite frame. The spacing of the metallic grommets along the central black panels was engineered to sit tighter, ensuring the heavy, mirror-encrusted fringe cleared the club floor without sacrificing the original, dizzying optical illusion Mackie intended.
To complete the mid-70s television homage, Carpenter’s beauty look leaned entirely into retro glamour. She traded her signature bouncy, 90s-inspired blowout for tight, voluminous disco curls. Her makeup featured heavy lower-lash mascara clumping—a direct nod to Cher’s mid-decade aesthetic—paired with towering silver platform sandals designed to give the fringe maximum swinging velocity on the dance floor.
Inheriting the Pop Throne
This isn’t an isolated fashion moment; it’s a calculated pattern. At the previous year’s VMAs, Carpenter turned heads in the exact white, heavily beaded Bob Mackie gown that Madonna wore to the 1991 Academy Awards.
By systematically targeting pieces worn by Madonna and Cher—arguably the two most untouchable architects of the modern pop star blueprint—Carpenter is executing a brilliant visual narrative. She isn’t just wearing clothes; she is aligning her rapidly rising stardom with the legacy of fashion’s most fearless pioneers. In an era dominated by hyper-speed, disposable digital trends, Carpenter’s deep dive into the Bob Mackie archive establishes her as a pop star who doesn’t just want to rule the charts—she wants to inherit the throne.
Lorin Gutierrez-Bektas is on the cover of STYLISH Magazine right now. In our latest cover story, discover how she’s carving her own path and challenging what success looks like for today’s generation.
Read the current Stylish Magazine cover story here.
Our #StylishPodcast episode featuring our September-October cover girl Jasmine Curtis-Smith is out. Watch it on Facebook and YouTube.
Stylish Magazine is “your source of self-love, style & inspiration” first introduced in June 2020. Our television series format, Stylish TV, once ranked one of the Top 50 Most Watched Multicultural Shows in the USA, can be streamed on iWantTFC and be watched on TFC (The Filipino Channel) in more than 50 countries. Watch it online here.
Style Visionary Network is a lifestyle-business online platform where #WeCreateVisionaries. Also introduced in June 2020, Style Visionary Network is also the digital home channel of media brands Stylish Magazine and Stylish TV.